1. “Removing the per-country cap increases immigration.”

    Short answer: It adds no green cards and no visas. It changes the order in which the existing green cards are issued.1,2,3,4,5

    Congress sets the number of employment-based green cards each year. The per-country cap in INA §202(a)(2) does not set that number; it decides who among qualified applicants receives the green cards first, based on country of birth.

    The Fairness for High-Skilled Immigrants Act and the EAGLE Act of 2021 would have removed the per-country cap for employment-based green cards and left the annual number unchanged. They would have added no green cards and no temporary work visas. Most of the people who would receive green cards sooner already live and work in the United States on temporary visas.

    In fiscal year 2024, 69% of employment-based green cards (118,410 of 171,120) went to people who adjusted status inside the United States rather than arriving on an immigrant visa (DHS, 2024 Yearbook of Immigration Statistics, Table 7). The Congressional Research Service stated in 2020 that most prospective employment-based immigrants in the backlog already reside in the United States.

  2. “Without a per-country cap, applicants from one or two countries would take nearly all employment-based green cards for years.”

    Short answer: The EAGLE Act of 2021 would have phased the change in over nine years, with rules to keep green cards from all going to one country.3,6,7,8,9,10,11,12

    If the cap were removed at once, the applicants who have waited longest, born in India and China, would be at the front of a single line.

    The bills would not have removed it at once. Under the EAGLE Act of 2021, the change would have taken effect at the start of the second fiscal year after the bill became law. Transition rules for EB-2 and EB-3 green cards would then have applied for nine fiscal years. During that period, a set share of those green cards (30% in the first year, falling to 5% in the last three, plus a further 5.75% each year, first for family members joining a worker already in the United States) would have been reserved for applicants born outside the two countries with the highest demand. No single country could have received more than 85% of the green cards that were not reserved. After it, green cards would have gone to applicants in the order they applied.

    The version the Senate passed in December 2020 added a different limit. Through the ninth fiscal year after the bill’s effective date, no more than 70% of the employment-based green cards issued in a year could go to people who are, or in the past two years were, H-1B holders, together with the spouses and children of those people who are, or were, H-4 holders; after that, no more than 50%. Applicants who graduated from medical school and will practice medicine in the United States, and applicants granted a national interest waiver, were exempt.

    The Congressional Research Service did not model the EAGLE Act. In a December 2018 report it looked at the “Yoder Amendment,” a version of the Fairness for High-Skilled Immigrants Act (H.R.392, 115th Congress) that would have been attached to the 2019 Department of Homeland Security appropriations bill (H.R.6776) and would have phased out the per-country ceiling over four years. For the third employment-based preference category only, CRS estimated that “roughly four to five years would be required to eliminate this queue of prospective 3rd preference employment-based immigrants”: about 170,000 applicants and family members from India, China and the Philippines who were waiting in 2018. CRS called the calculation “illustrative, not … a projection.”

  3. “Applicants from countries with short waits today would have to wait longer.”

    Short answer: During a transition, the EAGLE Act of 2021 would have set aside a share of green cards for applicants from other countries. Future applicants from those countries would wait longer than now, and applicants from India and China much less.3,6,7,13

    This objection is partly right, and the answer depends on who is asking.

    During the transition. For nine fiscal years after the change would have taken effect, the EAGLE Act of 2021 would have reserved a set share of EB-2 and EB-3 green cards (30% in the first year, falling to 5% in the last three, plus a further 5.75% each year, first for family members joining a worker already in the United States) for applicants born outside the two countries with the highest demand.

    Future applicants. People who apply after the change, from countries with short waits today, would wait longer than they do now, because everyone would be in the same line.

    Applicants from India and China would wait much less, because their place in line would depend on when they applied, not where they were born. The National Foundation for American Policy estimated in August 2026 that an India-born applicant with an EB-2 filing from January 2026 or later faces a potential wait of 179 years under current law.

  4. “It will cut the supply of foreign nurses and physical therapists that hospitals rely on.”

    Short answer: The EAGLE Act of 2021 would have set aside at least 4,400 green cards a year for nurses and physical therapists for the first seven years of the transition.6,7,8,14

    This concern was raised in the Senate while the bill was before it in 2019 and 2020. IV’s account is that Senators Rand Paul and David Perdue placed holds on the bill to obtain carve-outs for foreign nurses, and that Senator Mike Lee negotiated with them.

    The EAGLE Act of 2021 addressed the concern directly. For the first seven fiscal years of the transition, it would have set aside at least 4,400 EB-3 green cards a year for nurses and physical therapists. Spouses and children would not have counted against the 4,400.

  5. “It mainly helps large tech and outsourcing companies that rely on H-1B workers.”

    Short answer: The EAGLE Act of 2021 paired the change with new limits on H-1B employers, including a 50% cap and a bar on using visitor visas for work that needs an H-1B.6,7,8,15,16

    Critics of the H-1B program say some employers, especially outsourcing firms, use it to hire cheaper workers in place of Americans. Immigration Voice shares part of that concern: its mission is to protect “immigrants and American workers alike, so bad employers cannot use immigrants with fewer rights to replace American workers.”

    The EAGLE Act of 2021 would have placed these limits on employers:

    • A requirement to post jobs on a searchable Department of Labor website for at least 30 days before filing for a new H-1B worker.
    • A bar on new H-1B filings by an employer with 50 or more employees in the United States if more than half of its US staff held H-1B or L-1 visas.
    • A ban on using visitor (B) visas for work that would normally need an H-1B visa.
    • A ban on advertising jobs as open only to H-1B workers, or as giving them preference.
    • A requirement to state how the employer determined the prevailing wage, and to give the Department of Labor the W-2s of H-1B workers it had employed in a period the Secretary specified.
    • Liability for lost wages and benefits for employers that retaliated against workers who reported violations.
    • New Department of Labor audit and investigation powers, and roughly tripled fines for labor condition application violations.

    The bill would also have let workers whose immigrant petitions were approved at least two years earlier apply for a green card early and move to a job in the same or a similar occupation while they waited. IV’s position is that a worker who can leave is harder to underpay, which removes an incentive for an employer to prefer a visa holder over an American.

  6. “It will hold down wages for American workers in the same jobs.”

    Short answer: Workers tied to one employer for years have less bargaining power. The bill shortens that wait, and the EAGLE Act of 2021 would have let workers with approved petitions change jobs sooner.3,6,7,17

    The concern is that workers waiting for green cards accept lower pay because they cannot easily change jobs, and that this pulls down pay for others in the same field.

    Immigration Voice agrees that workers tied to one employer for years have less bargaining power. Its answer is to shorten that time. With a single line, the wait no longer depends on country of birth, and workers with approved petitions could change jobs sooner under the EAGLE Act of 2021.

    In October 2018, David Bier of the Cato Institute compared the wages employers offered in approved EB-2 and EB-3 labor certifications for fiscal year 2018. Applicants from India and China, who wait longest, were offered more on average ($118,071 and $111,172) than applicants from other countries ($90,422), and were more likely to be offered jobs requiring more experience and skills. Because the cap holds back the higher-paid applicants, he estimated that it lowers the average wage of new employer-sponsored immigrants by $11,592: $95,534 with the cap, against $107,126 without it.

    The EAGLE Act of 2021 would also have required employers to state on each labor condition application how they determined the prevailing wage, and to give the Department of Labor the W-2s of H-1B workers they had employed in a period the Secretary specified.

  7. “The answer is less immigration, not a different order in the same line.”

    Short answer: The bill does not change immigration levels. It changes the order of the existing line, not its size, and IV does not advocate bringing in more immigrants under the current system.3,16,18

    Some people who favor lower immigration oppose any change to employment-based immigration until the overall numbers come down.

    The per-country cap bill does not change the overall numbers. It applies to people who already qualify for a green card, most of whom already live and work in the United States.

    Immigration Voice describes itself as “pro-immigrant” rather than “pro-immigration.” Its mission page says: “We never have, and never will, advocate to bring more immigrants from outside of the United States under the current flawed system.” Its aim is fair treatment and basic rights for immigrants already here, so that they cannot be exploited and US workers are not undercut.

Sources

  1. 8 U.S.C. §1152(a)(2) (INA §202(a)(2)): per country levels for family-sponsored and employment-based immigrants, Legal Information Institute, Cornell Law School (accessed 2026-11-14)
  2. The Fairness Bill (immigrationvoice.org/the-fairness-bill/, archived copy), Immigration Voice, 2021-01-03 (accessed 2026-11-14) Last updated Jan 3, 2021 (first published Sep 13, 2020); archived Apr 15, 2026. The rebuilt site redirects this page to The issue.
  3. The EAGLE Act: Myths vs Facts, Immigration Voice, 2021 (accessed 2026-11-14) The EAGLE Act site (eagleact.info, 2021) is offline; archived copy of Oct 1, 2021.
  4. Table 7. Persons Obtaining Lawful Permanent Resident Status by Type and Detailed Class of Admission: Fiscal Year 2024, DHS Office of Homeland Security Statistics, Fiscal year 2024 (accessed 2026-11-14) Employment-based preferences: 171,120 in all, of whom 118,410 adjusted status inside the United States and 52,710 were new arrivals.
  5. The Employment-Based Immigration Backlog (CRS Report R46291), Congressional Research Service, 2020-03-26 (accessed 2026-11-14) By William A. Kandel. "Most prospective employment-based immigrants in the backlog already reside in the United States."
  6. The EAGLE Act of 2021: section-by-section summary, Immigration Voice, 2021 (accessed 2026-11-14) The EAGLE Act site (eagleact.info, 2021) is offline; archived copy of Oct 1, 2021.
  7. H.R.3648, Equal Access to Green cards for Legal Employment Act of 2021 (EAGLE Act of 2021), as introduced, U.S. Government Publishing Office (govinfo), 2021-06-01 (accessed 2026-11-14) Reported by the House Judiciary Committee on June 7, 2022 as the EAGLE Act of 2022 (H. Rept. 117-353), with an added bar on foreign-media representatives using the H-1B and minor drafting changes to the effective-date wording: reported text.
  8. House Report 117-353, Equal Access to Green Cards for Legal Employment Act of 2022, House Committee on the Judiciary, 2022-06-07 (accessed 2026-11-14) Ordered reported 22–14 on Apr 6, 2022. Includes a section-by-section analysis of H.R.3648.
  9. S.386-Fairness for High-Skilled Immigrants Act passes the Senate!, Immigration Voice, 2020-12-02
  10. H.R.1044, Fairness for High-Skilled Immigrants Act, Senate amendment (EAS), U.S. Government Publishing Office (govinfo), 2020-12-02 (accessed 2026-11-14) Sec. 8, new INA 245(o): the 70% and 50% limits for current and recent H-1B holders and their H-4 family members, and the exemptions for medical-school graduates and national interest waiver holders.
  11. Permanent Employment-Based Immigration and the Per-country Ceiling (CRS Report R45447), Congressional Research Service, 2018-12-21 (accessed 2026-11-14) By William A. Kandel. Version 3, updated December 21, 2018. The four-to-five-year estimate is on printed page 19 (footnote 67). It covers the third employment-based preference under the 2018 Yoder Amendment, and CRS calls the calculation illustrative, not a projection.
  12. The Fairness For High-Skilled Immigrants Act added as an amendment to the DHS Appropriations bill!, Immigration Voice, 2018-07-25
  13. Employment-Based Immigration Backlogs and Waiting Times (NFAP Policy Brief), National Foundation for American Policy, August 2026 (accessed 2026-11-14) Estimates a potential wait of 179 years in EB-2 (38 years in EB-3) for an India-born applicant whose labor certification or immigrant petition is filed in January 2026 or later. Puts the backlog in the first three employment-based categories at 1,264,495 in December 2025: USCIS counts of approved petitions plus an estimate of spouses and children (59% dependents, from FY 2024). About 79% were born in India.
  14. Senator Durbin lifts his hold over Fairness for High-Skilled Immigrants Act (S.386), Immigration Voice, 2020-08-05
  15. The EAGLE Act: Overview (The Problem, The Solution), Immigration Voice, 2021 (accessed 2026-11-14) The EAGLE Act site (eagleact.info, 2021) is offline; archived copy of Oct 1, 2021.
  16. Mission (immigrationvoice.org/mission/, archived copy), Immigration Voice, 2021-01-28 (accessed 2026-11-14) Dated Jan 28, 2021 in this archived copy (first published Aug 12, 2020); archived Apr 15, 2026. The live page was edited on Jun 27, 2026 and the quoted lines are unchanged.
  17. Higher-paid Immigrants Forced to Wait Longer Due to Per-country Limits, Cato Institute, 2018-10-22 (accessed 2026-08-11) By David J. Bier, Cato at Liberty blog. Figures from approved EB-2 and EB-3 labor certifications, fiscal year 2018. Read on the Internet Archive capture of 11 August 2026.
  18. The difference between "Pro-Immigrant" & "Pro-Immigration", Immigration Voice, 2016-03-07

Back to The issue